Categories
Patient Education

11 things you must know before undergoing hysterectomy

Mrs. Saluja is a professor of bio technology. Her gynaecologist has advised her a surgery for removal of uterus (hysterectomy) and the same was scheduled the next day. Her close relative had almost dragged her to me, insisting that I should see her once and opine. Mrs. Saluja seemed very sure and clear about everything. When I asked her these questions she looked puzzled. She did not know the answers and had not asked these questions to her doctor too.

Here I share are those eleven things you must know before undergoing hysterectomy

  1. What is Hysterectomy? : It is surgical removal of uterus. It is a common surgery that women undergo during their life time.
  2. Are ovaries going to be removed? : Ovaries are power house of the hormones. Removal of ovaries will lead to sudden deficiency of hormones. This will lead to symptoms of menopause. The skin may go dry, hair brittle, hot flushes etc. If you have already attained the menopause or on the verge of attaining it, it is fair to remove the ovaries; but not otherwise. Of course if the ovaries are diseased doctor may consider removal of the ovaries.
  3. Are there any alternative treatments available? : It is true that removal of uterus might be the ultimate solution to many of the problems. But there can be many other alternatives. These alternatives depend on what is the basic gynaecological condition that you have. You should discuss with your doctor about the options
  4. Is the removal of uterus possible through the natural orifice of vagina?  : The surgery can be done by three ways: Open surgery on abdomen, laparoscopy and vaginal surgery. Endoscopic surgery or laparoscopy is definitely better option as compared to open surgery. However even better option is to go for surgery through natural orifice that means vaginal surgery. Some doctors are able to do this surgery through vaginal route even if the uterus is large or has fibroids. Check with your doctor on this.
  5. What are the common complications? : Every surgery has its share of complications. The uterus has to be separated from the adjoining structures that is the urinary bladder and the intestines. Excessive bleeding, wound infection are two other common problems that can occur.
  6. How fast will you be able to resume work/ exercise? : It is important to know how early you can resume your work. One does not need weeks and months of rest after the surgery. Vaginal surgery leads to quickest recovery followed by laparoscopic one. One may have to resort to abdominal surgery if the uterus is too big or has large fibroids.
  7. Is there a suspicion of cancer? : It is important to understand why are you undergoing the surgery. If there is a suspicion of cancer, you must know what investigations are needed further.
  8. What is the cost? : Do not forget to ask the cost of the surgery before you go ahead.
  9. Are you sure about preparation before surgery? : Has your doctor adequately investigated you before surgery? Are you aware of when should you eat or drink last? Have you got clear instructions on preparation before surgery? Do you take any medicines that need to be stopped prior to surgery? Ask these questions to your doctor.
  10. Have you disclosed all the details about yourself? : Do not forget to disclose all the details about yourself. If you are suffering from common problems such as high blood pressure or diabetes or thyroid you must disclose it. Are you allergic to any medicines? Have you undergone a surgery in the past? Do share this information with the doctor.
  11. What anaesthesia is going to be used? : There are two broad categories. General anaesthesia where you are completely anaesthetised and regional anaesthesia in which only certain part… in this case only part below the belly button is anaesthetised. Anaesthesia depends upon the nature of surgery, medical conditions, patient’s choice and doctor’s choice.

 

Categories
Blogs by Dr. Nikhil Datar

Email communication with the doctors: Good practices shared by patient herself

I proudly share this article penned down by my patient Swati Iyer.

I recently consulted Dr. Nikhil Datar for my ongoing pregnancy. After a thorough examination of the files and a check-up, he recommended that get a few additional tests done immediately and I come back to him with the reports. I stay at the other end of town. Given the Mumbai traffic it is tough to travel some times. I checked if I could send him the reports via e-mail and then follow up with a visit in the following week, to which he readily agreed.

( source: Google)
I received the test results in a couple of days (there were a bunch of reports that seemed like Greek and Latin to me!) and I was unsure how could I send them to him in a way that would be easy for him to read the respond quickly. Dr Datar is a renowned and busy doctor who deals with many patients on day to day basis. Email being a non-personal communication, with no ability to get clarifications across (unlike a face-to-face meeting), I felt it was necessary for me to ensure I provide him with all the required information at hand, so that he does not have to rely on his memory to respond to my email, while also ensuring there is a right context to the reports I was sending to him.

 

So here’s what I used as a frame work while I wrote an email:

 

  1. Name of Patient (Obviously!)
  2. Date of first consultation
  3. Place of consultation (i.e name of the hospital/clinic)
  4. Purpose of consultation and the follow up actions that was recommended by the Doctor
  5. The test reports, along with photographs/ scans
  6. My questions regarding follow up actions, if any, required and/or the suggested next steps to be taken. I asked very specific questions. I did not ask non-specific question like “What should I do?”. I asked specific question such as “Should I take XYZ medicine?”

Tip: If you are attaching multiple reports or scans, it’s a good idea to label (filename) each file so that the Doctor can quickly identify the report it corresponds to.

Needless to add, my email had a prompt response and guess what, I was pleasantly surprised when he told me that this was the best email query written by a patient. He appreciated the methodical manner and further said “It made my life easy. I could correlate easily and respond immediately.” Besides that it also reduces the chances of errors too.

If you follow these simples steps it can make things easy, fast and accurate for yourself as well as your doctor!

Categories
Patient Education

Love making during pregnancy

Sneha and Arun walked into my cabin. The couple was excited about the first baby. It was just third month of pregnancy and second visit to me. This time the mother was also accompanying the couple. The mother looked happy and watchful too. After the consultation we had a quick chat and then they got up to leave. This time Arun allowed the mother to exit first and turned back with a shy smile. Sneha looked in two minds… Whether to ask or not to ask? And I knew the question that was coming my way. As expected the question was about whether they could have sex or no?

Most Indian couples do not discuss this with anyone. They rely on myths and beliefs or lay literature. This adds further confusion! Like the famous Shake sphere’s quote “To do or not to do, that is the real (unanswered) question” for the young couples. Commonly people believe that sex during pregnancy is a big NO- NO. People believe that intercourse can harm the pregnancy. Surprisingly many doctors also advice the same to their patients! While few advice not to have sex in first three months and some advice not to have sex when the bump grows bigger!! So what does the evidence say?

Well, there is a clear scientific evidence that sex during pregnancy can NOT harm the baby per say. However there are few conditions such as placenta praevia (placenta is low placed), repeated miscarriages, opened up or short cervix, previous premature deliveries or if there is bleeding or leaking most doctors will advise against intercourse. It is important to understand that the baby is inside a balloon of water which is inside the uterus. The lower end of the uterus called cervix is closed and plugged with a mucus plug which does not allow entry of even germs (microorganisms) upwards.

 

The baby inside the balloon of water in the uterus which has closed cervix

However it is also important to understand that although the baby is protected the woman can contact infections from her male partner. These infections could be simple fungal infection, bacterial, viral infection too. In order to prevent such infections it is better to use a condom (or barrier contraceptive). During the pregnancy the hormones in the body surge making the tissues softer and congested. So a pregnant woman may rarely experience few drops of bleeding after intercourse.

So here are few tips for the young couples:

In first three months pregnant woman may feel exhausted due to nausea, vomiting and may not feel interested in sex. The partner must understand her problem and support her.

In second trimester and third trimester, the increasing bump needs to be taken into consideration. Change of position may help. Many women find “side to side” or “woman on top” position more comfortable.

Especially after six months most women may find it more and more uncomfortable. Some may feel minimal uterine contractions which are “innocent”. Intimacy does not necessarily mean penetrative sexual intercourse. The couple can make love without penetrative intercourse too.

In this delicate period of pregnancy, women undergo a complete emotional and physical turmoil. The partner must encourage her, caress her, support her. Sexual intercourse is perfectly fine if the woman is comfortable. Expression of love is important and being intimate is a necessity!

By Dr Nikhil Datar
MD DNB FCPS FICOG DGO DHA LLB
Consultant Gynaecologist & Medical Director Cloudnine Hospital
Consultant Gynaecologist Lifewave Hospital & Yashada Hospital
www.mygynaec.com

Categories
Patient Education

Are you taking iron tablets correctly?

Anemia is a common health problem amongst women in India. Iron tablets is the most common medicine prescribed medicine for this. All pregnant women are given a tablet of iron.
Iron tablets can be very effective but only if they are taken correctly.

Here are ten things you must know about iron intake.

  1.  Iron is best absorbed when taken on empty stomach. But it can cause cramps, acidity, vomiting when taken on empty stomach. That is why we advice to take iron tablet be taken after small quantity of food especially when they are not tolerated on empty stomach.
  2. Indian meal is full of phytates and phosphates. These ingredients hamper iron absorption. So never take iron immediately food. You may take it after some time.
  3. It is a common practice in India to take medicines with milk. This is a big “NO- NO”. It does not allow iron absorption.
  4. Conventional iron tablets should not be taken with calcium as this may reduce the absorption. However there are few iron salts which can be taken with calcium.
  5. Vitamin C improves iron absorption. It is a good idea to take iron with lime juice or orange juice.
  6. Common side effects of iron are constipation, dark stools, diarrhoea, nausea.
  7. It is commonly believed that beet root, carrot are best sources of iron. This is not true. Green leafy vegetables, walnuts, black grapes, dates are good vegetarian sources of iron.
  8. Haem Iron, the iron from Non vegetarian source is better absorbed in the body as compared to vegetarian sources.
  9. iron syrups may stain the teeth dark.
  10. Iron comes in the form of various salts. If you do not tolerate one type of salt discuss with your doctor and get it changed. But take the iron tablet and prevent anemia. Be healthy!

By Dr Nikhil Datar
MD DNB FCPS FICOG DGO DHA LLB
Consultant Gynaecologist & Medical Director Cloudnine Hospital
Consultant Gynaecologist Lifewave Hospital & Yashada Hospital
www.mygynaec.com

Categories
Blogs by Dr. Nikhil Datar

Controlling PCOS without medicines

PCOS, or polycystic ovarian syndrome, is a common hormonal disorder in women that interferes with the ovulation. It is the most common cause of infertility among women. PCOS occurs when a woman’s body overproduces sex hormones, called androgens. The hormone imbalance prevents fluid-filled sacs in the ovaries from breaking open and releasing mature eggs. The fluid-filled sacs bunch together, causing many tiny cysts.

PCOS Symptoms :

Why does polycystic ovary syndrome cause weight gain?

PCOS makes it more difficult for the body to use the hormone insulin , which normally helps convert sugars and starches from foods into energy. This condition — called insulin resistance — can cause insulin and sugar to build up in the bloodstream.

High insulin levels increase the production of male hormones called androgens. High androgen levels lead to weight gain.

Furthermore, insulin resistance and weight gain can lead to Type 2 diabetes, high cholesterol, high blood pressure and sleep apnea.

Many of these conditions can lead to heart disease . In fact, women with PCOS are four to seven times more likely to have a heart attack than women of the same age without the condition.

PCOS diet – DO’s and Don’ts :

Do’s:

High-fiber foods can help combat insulin resistance by slowing down digestion and reducing the impact of sugar on the blood. This may be beneficial to women with PCOS. Great options for high-fiber foods include:

  • cruciferous vegetables, such as broccoli, cauliflower, and Brussels sprouts

  • greens, including red leaf lettuce and arugula

  • green and red peppers

  • beans and lentils

  • almonds

  • berries

  • sweet potatoes

  • winter squash

  • pumpkin

Lean protein sources like tofu, chicken, and fish don’t provide fiber but are very filling and a healthy dietary option for women with PCOS.

Don’ts:

Refined carbohydrates cause inflammation, exacerbate insulin resistance, and should be avoided. These include highly processed foods, such as:

  • white bread

  • muffins

  • breakfast pastries

  • sugary desserts

  • white potatoes

  • anything made with white flour

PCOS, like many disorders, responds positively to proactive lifestyle choices. This includes exercise and daily physical movement. Both can help to reduce insulin resistance, especially when coupled with a limited intake of unhealthy carbohydrates. Many experts agree that at least 150 minutes per week of exercise is ideal.

Daily activity, low sugar intake, and a low-inflammation diet may also lead to weight loss. Women may experience improved ovulation with weight loss, so women who are obese or overweight and want to get pregnant may find physician-approved exercise especially important.

We cannot cure PCOS, but we absolutely can control it!

Pre-Pregnancy Counseling

Categories
Patient Education

Is seeking telephonic advice worth?

Social media and mobile have become an integral part of our life. We are connected to our family, friends and to market places by internet and social media all the time. Doctor is a crucial person in every one’s life. Being connected with the doctor makes everyone feel secure and safe. Naturally patients use social media like WhatsApp or mobile for quick advice when in need. The two commonest questions that are asked are “Is this worrisome?” “Can you suggest some medicine on phone?”
Here I share a real life story. A nine month pregnant patient’s mother called me on a Sunday afternoon stating that her daughter has slight bleeding but no pain and indicated that she may bring her to the hospital if pain increases. She wanted my nod to the plan. On the face of it the symptoms seemed “No worries” type… However knowing the case I simply told her to come to the hospital. No sooner she reached the hospital we diagnosed that it was a serious problem called “Abruption”. A life was saved only because we could examine the patient and not rely on the mother’s version.
Here are some fundamental problems with telephonic consultations.
• Detailed history, verbal and non-verbal clues which are picked up during face to face consultation and examination are necessary for accurate diagnosis. Had that been untrue, software could have diagnosed medical conditions! Just key in the complaints or symptoms and software gives you the diagnosis. Thus telephonic consultations to “quick fix” the problem can go miserably wrong some times.
• A doctor may or may not recollect the complete and minute details of the history (Say history of allergy to a particular drug) while on phone.
• While attending to some other important work and simultaneously speaking on phone there may be lack of attention.
• Both parties may not hear correctly on phone.
• Name of medications can go completely wrong when taken down on the phone. Even today while I write this article I saw a patient who had taken down a wrong spelling of a medicine during telephonic conversation.
Social media or phones are not basically meant for a serious professional conversation ( exception: pre decided conference call or pre-decided telephonic consultation). So what is the solution? How to seek help in emergency? How to stay connected with the healthcare provider without compromising on safety?
Here are some tips:
1 Ask your doctor what is the preferred mode of communication. In my experience I have found email to be the best. They are usually written and read by certain degree of seriousness.
2 You must have all the contact details of the hospital. You must know how the hospital has organised emergency medical service or “out of hour” service.
3 In case you call the doctor, keep your medical papers handy. Keep a pen and paper ready so that you can quickly write down.
4 You may remember this simple acronym “N-C-C-Q” and give the details accordingly .This can make the conversation productive and safe.
• Name: Full name
Resist conversations such as “Hi Doctor! Recognised me? I am Shilpa” You are not calling the doctor to test his/her memory. Are you?
• Case details:
Resist Conversation such as “Last time you gave me red coloured tablet…”
Instead say important things like you are pregnant, six months pregnant or not pregnant. You had visited for XYZ symptoms or was diagnosed as “ABC”. You have diabetes or blood pressure etc.
• Current problem:
Explain the current problem. Say “ I have got cough since two days.”
• Question
Do not ask vague question like “ Is this worrisome? ???? ???? ?? ?????” Instead ask specific questions like “What should I do next?” It is preferable not to ask for medications on the phone. The medical council guidelines prohibit telephonic advice on medications.( Over the counter products are exception)
You have to understand the limitations of the doctor and not expect a very detailed advice. Doctor can at the most give some temporary solution.
When in doubt it is always better to go to the hospital, Even if your doctor is not available, there will be medical personnel, doctor or a nurse who can make basic assessment and inform your doctor so that your doctor get the correct picture to help you out.
In conclusion, telephonic advice is not the best advice. Don’t underestimate your concerns by casual talks on phone, they need serious attention!
clipart_telefoneren_animaatjes-24

Categories
Blogs by Dr. Nikhil Datar

Boys! It is your turn now!!

Mr. Shankaran is a nice man. I know him since few years now. His wife came to me for treatment during pregnancy. Both the children were delivered by me. They are a lively couple with two beautiful children. This time they came to discuss with me about contraception. Nalini ( Name changed) said that she wants a permanent method which is hassle free. Shankaran was fully in support. He wanted a safe and simple method. I looked straight into them and said “Shankaran, why don’t you undergo a vasectomy operation?” And he looked at me with complete disbelief! “You mean me? I should undergo surgery? It is women’s job. Isn’t it?” was his immediate reaction.
Such reactions are not uncommon at all aamongst Indian males when it comes to family planning. For years together family welfare and contraception was considered to be the female’s responsibility. Most men are “kind of” least concerned about this topic in women’s health. Naturally female sterilization gained significant popularity in India. The NGO, “Health Rights Watch” published a report in 2012 stating that female surgery is socially more acceptable.
In our society men and women both are under genuine impression that male sterilization will reduce the vigour and virility of the male counterpart. They may not be able to perform sex. They may not be able build their bodies or pump their biceps. They may get tired to fast. Let me tell you that all these are 100 % misconceptions.
In fact this procedure is one of the safest medical procedures. The nature has kept male genitalia out side the body. So the “male tube/ Nas” (vas difference) lies just below the skin of the scrotum. It is obvious that it can be reached very easily. In case of a woman the female tube (fallopian tube) is inside the tummy, deep down …next to her uterus. Naturally for a female sterilization one needs to make a small key hole on the abdomen and reach to the tube. All this will obviously need anaesthesia too. In case of a male, it can be done under local anaesthesia or just a sedation. In the new technique called no scalpel vasectomy one does not need even a single stitch on the skin. The man can actually walk out of the operation room and go home in some time. The man does not need to take prolonged rest and can resume work on the next day.
Out of all the family planning surgeries performed in India not even 10% are male sterilizations. China performs better than us. In developed countries such as UK, USA and Australia the proportion of male sterilizations is much higher. In some countries it exceeds the number of female sterilizations.
The modern men need to be aware of this. I see that men are taking their share of responsibilities in upbringing of the children. The time has come that they take important role in controlling their family size too.
I am happy to note that state of Maharashtra has shown highest number of male surgeries in 2016. The special officer, family welfare Dr Asha Advani and her team must be congratulated for that. I strongly believe in the ease and safety of male family planning surgery. And I am proud to say that as a part of inauguration of my Lifewave Hospital we had conducted vasectomy camp in which we provided the surgeries completely free of cost!
Boys its ur turn

Categories
Blogs by Dr. Nikhil Datar

Is baby massage helpful?

My patient shared a video of her baby’s massage or “Malish”. I was aghast and dumb stuck looking at the way the “Malishwali” lady was doing the baby massage. I shared the video on face book and other social media and it went viral! It has got more than 260000 views in a span to 2 days. Many women called me or sent messages to thank me for this video. Many expressed that “whether to massage or no” is a common reason of conflict between the new and old generation. Thus I thought of penning down this article on Do’s and Don’ts of baby massage.
Oil massage to the new born is an age old practice in our country. Ayurveda describes “Abhyangam” &“ Mardan” as a therapy. It does state that “Abhyangam” if correctly done improves circulation and muscle tone. However over centuries the original science has got drowned in the mysterious myths. It is common to see that “Malsihwali Bai” continuing to do unscientific massage followed by so called “exercises”… Even senior ladies in the family allow it under the genuine belief that it is beneficial to the baby!! Here are some myths regarding baby massage and exercises:
• baby becomes tall
• baby ‘s joints become flexible
• the skin, eyes improve
• resistance power improves
• baby sleeps well.
Let me tell you that there is NO scientific evidence to any of the above. But it is true that one has no counter argument when senior ladies in the house say that they have been seeing/ doing this for so many years and nothing has gone wrong so far. Honestly that is the real problem to tackle. I spoke to many paediatricians, orthopaedic surgeons and Ayruveda practitioners. All confirmed that they have seen complications and problems because of wrongly done massage and/or exercises.
I am sure all of us have taken an oil massage in our life? Do you like if someone gives a massage with “heavy hand”? Does your body not get soar and pain? Don’t you think that the babies will also be experiencing the same? Or just because the babies cannot talk we consider that they are happy while the massage and acrobatic exercises are being done?
When the Malishwali bai does some acrobatic stunts with the babies and claim that the legs get straight or baby starts walking early, we must understand few basics of anthropology. We see that a new born of an animal like cow or horse starts walking immediately after the birth. Does that happen to human babies? No. The human off springs take a while before they start even crawling. This means that the human body is not ready for doing certain acts till the human body reaches certain development. The bones are not fully ossified and joints are not fully ready for the movements.
Thus here are few tips regarding baby massage:
1.If the baby is sick, unwell, low birth weight, premature one should not be give massage without doctor’s advice
2.There is no specific recommendation on particular oil for massage.
The oil should be applied lightly in direction of the muscles.
3.It takes few months for the baby to develop the mechanism of controlling body temperature. Till then baby’s can really get cold or hot while bathing. You must cover the baby well.
4.

A complete NO to the baby exercises at any point of time. Even if you are an ambitious parent and want your child to be in gymnastics still is a big No!

Categories
Blogs by Dr. Nikhil Datar

Why India needs to reconsider 20 weeks cut off for abortions

Happy to share my article published in Times of India on 28th july 2016

While this article reaches the readers, doctors would have safely terminated the severely abnormal foetus of Miss X. It is a moment of pride that Miss X has been permitted access to legal abortion (despite crossing the cut off limit of 20 weeks) by the honourable Supreme Court of India. Transgressing beyond the literal interpretation, the judges have delivered progressive and path breaking judgement. It is indeed a big boost to the women’s rights movement in the country. Miss X approached the court and got justice, but what next?

How many women will require seeking judicial intervention? How many pregnancies are detected to have substantial anomalies after 20 weeks? How many women seek termination? We don’t have statistics. Many will be compelled to undergo illegal termination as it will amount to criminal act under section 312 of Indian penal code. Any Indian gynaecologist if asked will say that situation like Miss X is not so uncommon. Medically the chance of severe abnormality is around 1%. If we guess that only 1% abnormal pregnancies are detected after 20 weeks and given that many women give birth every year, we reach an astounding figure! It is almost like a public health hazard.

A pregnant woman develops an emotional bond with the unborn foetus by five months. It is a brutal shock to her when she is informed that the foetus in her womb has some serious abnormality and bears poor prognosis. It is a disaster when her brave decision to discontinue the pregnancy is overturned by doctors due to the legal limit of 20 weeks. So now we expect her to run to judiciary, appoint a lawyer, stay in the glare of the media (I must commend the sensitive handling by the Indian media here). Had she been below the limit of 20 weeks she would have exercised her right in a doctor’s clinic. So why punish her to run around? How many women will be brave enough to take such steps? Aren’t we compelling them to continue such an unwanted pregnancy risking their mental and physical health?

Miss X was lucky in a way. The abnormality was extremely serious and incompatible with life. The medical report given by me and KEM committee depicted it clearly. Imagine Mrs Y’s case (Mrs X and Mrs Y Vs Government of India) was in front of the court. I must give a brief about the case. Mrs Y was told just few days prior to 20 weeks cut off that there is some deviation in the brain structure of the foetus. The problem and severity could only be ascertained after removing the amniotic fluid (fluid around the baby). The report could take few weeks. Had she continued the pregnancy and then got the rude shock that the foetus was grossly abnormal, she would have had no choice but to approach the court like Miss X. The court would have appointed another board. The board would have again conducted fresh reports (the way KEM hospital reconfirmed all the facts again) and could have required another three weeks to opine.

It will be ideal if the parliament takes proactive stance in the matter. The directives from the apex court will go long way till then. In the recent past such directives have been issued in Aruna Shanbhag’s case in relation to passive euthanasia. These directives are being followed across the country and helping so many patients. The courts may be able to provide the frame work on appropriate interpretation of “substantial risk of handicap” as mentioned in the MTP Act. International guidelines from the Royal College of Obstetrics and Gynaecology in the UK, FIGO and many other international best practices can be ready reference points.

Abuse of such relaxations for sex determination (as feared by honourable Attorney general) is more perceived than real. Still to ensure safety and prevent abuse, medical boards can be set up. Needless to say, these provisions must be used only in exceptional situations.<br ?–>In light of modern medicine the cut off limit of 20 weeks also needs to be re-examined. In medical ethics there is a concept called “viability of the foetus”. It means capacity of independent existence. When the foetus is naturally expelled out before the age of viability, it is termed as “miscarriage”. When the same thing happens after the age of viability is termed as “delivery or labour”. Indian birth and death registration Act recognises birth when it occurs after 28 weeks of pregnancy. Just handful of babies have survived when born at 24 weeks… that too only when born in state of art premier institutes in the country. It can be construed that foetus expelled before 24 weeks is not “viable”. Thus raising the limit of termination to 24 weeks in general shall not make any difference from ethical or legal standpoint. The medicines and the method of termination of pregnancy remains the same at 18 weeks as well as 24 weeks. Besides, it is a well know medical fact that by 24 weeks of gestation woman can be provided with complete diagnosis as well as prognosis of abnormality. Thus women can make informed choices and decisions about terminations. Only upon crossing the limit women will need to approach the medical boards.

I think that it is just and fair that women in our country make informed choices and have the capacity of making decisions without pressure of arbitrary legal limits. Ultimately they and only they can deliver, breastfeed and raise the child.

Link: It’s time for India to reconsider 20-week cut-off for abortions

Categories
Blogs by Dr. Nikhil Datar

Once upon a time there was PCPNDT Act

Once upon a time there was a king. His kingdom had severe shortage of water. People used to suffer and die because of lack of water. One great architect built a huge reservoir of water. The citizens became happy as they could get sufficient water. Few goons started misusing the water for making an addictive drug. The people in the kingdom started getting addicted. The king was sad and angry. He decided to stop this completely. What he was doing was for the good for his citizens. The King told his ministers to stop this misuse at any cost. The brilliant ministers made a law called PCPNDT namely “Public control and prevention of Drugs & toxins (Misuse) Act”.
The ministers decided to make provisions to keep strict vigilance on the usage of water. Ultimately it was water that was misused. They made a stringent law. Any slightest violation of the law amounted to imprisonment and jail. So the intelligent ministers made following rules under the law:
• Every person who fetches water will first register by paying money and not fetch water without registration.
• Every person shall keep an accurate account of the amount of water used for every purpose measured in accurate manner in a prescribed format on daily basis and report online… that too before using the water. Thus a mother was supposed to first to do all administrative work before giving a glass of water to her child.
• Every person who fetches the water will keep his head and face uncovered so that his face shall be captured by the camera.
• Every person shall carry two boards of specific size in two languages in one hand stating that he shall not use the water for making the drug from the water. In the other hand the person shall carry the original license (no lamination allowed) and take care that the water is not spilt on it.
• Every person shall have a container only of a defined size, shape and colour.
The law was implemented. Everybody applauded the king for the great objective of the law. Still there were stories of addictive drug being available at places. Some addicts were willing to pay any price for the drug. There were some antisocial elements who were still making the drug and selling it at a steep price. The social workers made a big hue and cry and they were right. The next generation was getting addicted ultimately. Some social workers went to the extent that they wrote a letter to the king stating that the reservoir of water be shut so that there is no water for drinking … so that there will be no misuse of water. The king was kind enough not to listen to them but he got angry. He directed his officers to be very strict with the implementation of the law. The patriotic officers were working for the betterment of the country. Besides that there was a monetary incentive to find out the law breakers. Every body who was fetching the water was scrutinised and the paper work was checked thoroughly. For every smallest mistake in the paper work, cases were filed and arrests were made. The offenders were punished and put in the jail. The officers did not care whether the citizens were dying without water or otherwise. The officers reported to the king about efficient implementation of the law and gave an account of offenders that were booked and jailed. Actually no one was caught red handed while selling or making the drug. To tell you the truth they did not have a spy network or some mechanism for actually searching out the drug makers or pedellars. Most of the citizens that were booked were for faulty papers work. Some were arrested because they did not have a specific container, some were arrested because they first drank the water and then filled up the form and some were arrested because the license got wet. One person was arrested because his license to fetch the water had expired but the officer had delayed the renewal. And the man had to fetch water for daily chore. Now a mother would have to measure the water drunk by her child. The elderly and sick who could not go to the reservoir themselves or could not hold the container, boards and license at a time in two hands, could not get water at all.
Friends what do you think? Was the king right in making such a law? Would these mindless bureaucratic provisions work to solve the real problem? Will it not be better to improve the spy network and actually find out the real offenders?
If you think that the king should have understood this, then it is high time that you understand why doctors are agitating against the PCPNDT Act. Of course I am talking about the Pre-conceptional and prenatal diagnostic technique Act.
Dr Nikhil D Datar
Gynaecologist and Patient rights activist